PogoWasRight.org

Menu
  • About
  • Privacy
Menu

Ca: Local MADD chapter joins push for random breath testing

Posted on October 20, 2010July 3, 2025 by Dissent

Pat Healey reports:

Police may be able to stop drivers for random breath testing if Mothers Against Drunk Driving (MADD) is successful in its latest campaign.

MADD Canada is pushing the federal government to pass legislation that will allow officers to stop and ask anyone for a breath sample.

The past president of MADD Canada Margaret Miller said random breath testing would give police the express power to stop vehicles in a sobriety-type checkpoint.

“The main purpose is to be able to stop a group of vehicles, like they do in many countries, and they ask each driver for their license and insurance,” Miller said. “Along with the rest, you will also be asked for a breath sample. The purpose is basically to reduce the number of impaired driving deaths and injuries. We know that when it was first implemented in the 1980s in Australia that they saw within two years a 36 per cent reduction in death and injury.”

Read more in The Weekly Press.

If the tests are truly random, then there is no reasonable suspicion and no valid grounds to intrude on someone’s privacy. Would these advocates say that it’s okay for law enforcement to randomly sample people and read their e-mail or listen in on their phone calls?

A lot of well-intended ideas result in the erosion of privacy and civil liberties. Why not build the technology into cars to determine if the car should be started? Better that than having law enforcement demand a breathalyzer test. Advocates for the idea recognize the privacy concerns but dismiss them:

She admitted not everyone is supportive of the idea and that there are critics of the move to what some deem as an invasion of their privacy.

“The only ones who aren’t behind this are those who think this is violating their right,” Miller said. “Driving has never been a right. It’s always been a privilege. It’s a heavily-regulated activity that the infringement is no greater than what you will get on a plane.

“At the end it will make Canada a better place (to drive) for all Canadians.”

So if it’s okay for your privacy to be invaded in one situation, that justified expanding the privacy invasions to another situation? Amazing logic.

While we’re at it, why not randomly stop drivers and subject them to an EEG to see if they might have an epileptic condition that could cause a seizure while they’re driving? Or maybe we should stop drivers randomly and do a urine test for drugs that could impair them?

C’mon MADD, the goal of reducing avoidable road accidents and fatalities is a worthwhile goal, but this is not the way to do it.

Corey Laroque, who comments on the proposal in the Niagara Falls Review, seems to concur that this is a well-intended but bad idea, and suggests, instead, increasing the use of RIDE stops whereby everyone on a particular stretch of road is stopped.  While I’m not a fan of that approach, it would certainly be preferable to “random” tests — when we all know that “random” never turns out to be truly “random.”

No related posts.

Category: Featured NewsLawsNon-U.S.Surveillance

Post navigation

← Privacy Agency Says Banks Lack Transparency
FTC Testifies on the Rights of Employees Under the Fair Credit Reporting Act →

Now more than ever

Search

Contact Me

Email: info@pogowasright.org

Mastodon: Infosec.Exchange/@PogoWasRight

Signal: +1 516-776-7756

Categories

Recent Posts

  • Microsoft’s controversial Recall feature is now blocked by Brave and AdGuard
  • Trump Administration Issues AI Action Plan and Series of AI Executive Orders
  • Indonesia asked to reassess data privacy terms in new U.S. trade deal
  • Meta Denies Tracking Menstrual Data in Flo Health Privacy Trial
  • Wikipedia seeks to shield contributors from UK law targeting online anonymity
  • British government reportedlu set to back down on secret iCloud backdoor after US pressure
  • Idaho agrees not to prosecute doctors for out-of-state abortion referrals

RSS Recent Posts on DataBreaches.net

  • BreachForums — the one that went offline in April — reappears with a new founder/owner
  • Fans React After NASCAR Confirms Ransomware Breach
  • Allianz Life says ‘majority’ of customers’ personal data stolen in cyberattack
  • Infinite Services notifying employees and patients of limited ransomware attack
  • The safe place for women to talk wasn’t so safe: hackers leak 13,000 user photos and IDs from the Tea app
©2025 PogoWasRight.org. All rights reserved.
Menu
  • About
  • Privacy