PogoWasRight.org

Menu
  • About
  • Privacy
Menu

Ninth Circuit Signals That A Reasonable User Cannot Consent to Data Collection Via Confusing and Contradictory Privacy Disclosures

Posted on July 26, 2024 by Dissent

From EPIC.org:

Last week, the Ninth Circuit heard oral argumentheard arguments in Google v. Calhoun, a case about whether users really consented to Google’s collecting and sharing their data when Google’s own published policies said contradictory things about those practices. EPIC’s amicus brief asserted that Google cannot argue that consumers reasonably consented to its data practices when the company’s privacy policy said it would not engage in those practices, even though Google disclaimed any liability in its contradictory general disclosure terms. During oral argument, the judges signaled agreement with EPIC’s position.

In this case, plaintiffs sued because Google represented to Chrome users that it would not collect browsing history unless the users chose to sync that data to the cloud. But, in fact, Google did collect and transfer information about Chrome user’s browsing habits even if they did not choose to sync their data to the cloud. Google argued in its defense that these users had nevertheless consented to the collection and transfer of their sensitive browsing data based on general disclosures in its user agreement.

The Ninth Circuit judges seemed to agree with plaintiffs and EPIC, explaining that the federal judge had an 8-hour evidentiary hearing to understand the data collection practices and no reasonable user can be held to that standard to consent to them. One judge also said that reading complicated Terms of Service online is like reading hieroglyphics.

Read more at EPIC.

No related posts.

Category: BusinessCourt

Post navigation

← Invasion of the Data Snatchers: B.C. Court of Appeal Clarifies Possible Scope of Privacy Claims Against Data Custodians in Data Breaches
Department of Education Sued Following Markup Investigation Into FAFSA Data Shared with Facebook →

Now more than ever

Search

Contact Me

Email: info@pogowasright.org

Mastodon: Infosec.Exchange/@PogoWasRight

Signal: +1 516-776-7756

Categories

Recent Posts

  • Microsoft’s controversial Recall feature is now blocked by Brave and AdGuard
  • Trump Administration Issues AI Action Plan and Series of AI Executive Orders
  • Indonesia asked to reassess data privacy terms in new U.S. trade deal
  • Meta Denies Tracking Menstrual Data in Flo Health Privacy Trial
  • Wikipedia seeks to shield contributors from UK law targeting online anonymity
  • British government reportedlu set to back down on secret iCloud backdoor after US pressure
  • Idaho agrees not to prosecute doctors for out-of-state abortion referrals

RSS Recent Posts on DataBreaches.net

  • Scattered Spider is running a VMware ESXi hacking spree
  • BreachForums — the one that went offline in April — reappears with a new founder/owner
  • Fans React After NASCAR Confirms Ransomware Breach
  • Allianz Life says ‘majority’ of customers’ personal data stolen in cyberattack (1)
  • Infinite Services notifying employees and patients of limited ransomware attack
©2025 PogoWasRight.org. All rights reserved.
Menu
  • About
  • Privacy