PogoWasRight.org

Menu
  • About
  • Privacy
Menu

Sixth Circuit agrees with the Third, Seventh, and Tenth Circuits: a computer is not a file cabinet under the Fourth Amendment

Posted on June 7, 2011July 2, 2025 by Dissent

Alain Leibman comments:

An earlier post considered the wide array of analyses employed by the courts of appeal in assessing under the Fourth Amendment the constitutionality of searches of computers and other electronic storage devices. (An article by the author, expanding substantially on the short-form blog entry, may be found at “Computer Search and Seizure Under the Fourth Amendment: The Dilemma of Applying Old-Age Principles to New-Age Technology,” Criminal Law Reporter (March 2, 2011)). The differences among the courts turn on the degree to which they view the search of an electronic storage medium as like, or as unlike, a traditional search of a file drawer or other container of papers. A plurality of circuit courts have required law enforcement agents to proceed cautiously in searching through computers, cognizant both of the quantity of private data housed in a computer and the potentially corrosive effect on expectations of privacy when the “plain view” doctrine is used to justify a close review of data far afield from the original object of the search.

Read more on Lexology.

No related posts.

Category: CourtSurveillance

Post navigation

← A brief Sony password analysis
Do GPS Tracking Devices Violate the Fourth Amendment? →

Search

Contact Me

Email: info[at]pogowasright.org
Security Issue: security[at]pogowasright.org
Mastodon: Infosec.Exchange/@PogoWasRight
Signal: +1 516-776-7756
DMCA Concern: dmca[at]pogowasright.org

Research Report of Note

A report by EPIC.org:

State Attorneys General & Privacy: Enforcement Trends, 2020-2024

Categories

Recent Posts

  • EU justice chief draws red line on privacy reforms
  • Kaiser Permanente to Pay Up to $47.5M in Web Tracker Lawsuit
  • How Palantir shifted course to play key role in ICE deportations
  • U.S. Judge Blocks Trump From Cutting Medicaid Funding For Planned Parenthood In 22 States
  • India backs off mandatory ‘cyber safety’ app after surveillance backlash
  • Judge orders Trump administration to halt warrantless immigration arrests in District of Columbia
  • EU court says websites on the hook for user privacy harms

RSS Recent Posts at DataBreaches.net

  • Marquis data breach impacts over 74 US banks, credit unions
  • Virginia Twins Arrested for Conspiring to Destroy Government Databases
  • Cyberattack on Puerto Rico IT vendor Truenorth hits 3 agencies
  • Easy Question, Complicated Answer: What Does It Take to Stop Workers From Snooping?
  • Update on Dos-OP’s report on Nova RaaS
©2025 PogoWasRight.org. All rights reserved.