The Supreme Court’s decision issued this week upholding a Texas law requiring age verification to access pornography online has predictably drawn a lot of criticism from civil liberties and privacy advocates. Here’s EFF’s take on its impact, written by Aaron Mackey, Lisa Femia, and Jason Kelley:
Today’s decision in Free Speech Coalition v. Paxton is a direct blow to the free speech rights of adults. The Court ruled that “no person—adult or child—has a First Amendment right to access speech that is obscene to minors without first submitting proof of age.” This ruling allows states to enact onerous age-verification rules that will block adults from accessing lawful speech, curtail their ability to be anonymous, and jeopardize their data security and privacy. These are real and immense burdens on adults, and the Court was wrong to ignore them in upholding Texas’ law.
Importantly, the Court’s reasoning applies only to age-verification rules for certain sexual material, and not to age limits in general. We will continue to fight against age restrictions on online access more broadly, such as on social media and specific online features.
Still, the decision has immense consequences for internet users in Texas and in other states that have enacted similar laws. The Texas law forces adults to submit personal information over the internet to access entire websites that hold some amount of sexual material, not just pages or portions of sites that contain specific sexual materials. Many sites that cannot reasonably implement age verification measures for reasons such as cost or technical requirements will likely block users living in Texas and other states with similar laws wholesale.
Many users will not be comfortable sharing private information to access sites that do implement age verification, for reasons of privacy or concern for data breaches. Many others do not have a driver’s license or photo ID to complete the age verification process. This decision will, ultimately, deter adult users from speaking and accessing lawful content, and will endanger the privacy of those who choose to go forward with verification.
Read more at EFF.
And please consider donating to EFF. Free speech has been under tremendous assault by the current President and our cherished rights protected by the Constitution are suddenly being eroded by the legislature and Supreme Court. EFF has been a staunch defender of freedom of speech and privacy for years now. I’m proud to be a long-time supporter of their organization — Dissent.