PogoWasRight.org

Menu
  • About
  • Privacy
Menu

A judge asked a mother if she got the covid vaccine. She said no, and he revoked custody of her son.

Posted on August 30, 2021 by pogowasright.org

Jaclyn Peiser reports on what may be a first:

When Rebecca Firlit joined a virtual court hearing with her ex-husband earlier this month, the Chicago mother expected the proceedings to focus on child support.

To her surprise, the judge started by asking her whether she had been vaccinated  She replied that she had not been due to past adverse reactions to vaccines and the advice of her doctor.  Note that her vaccination status was not even an issue that had been raised to the court by her ex-husband or anyone.

Cook County Judge James Shapiro then made what the parents’ attorneys called an unprecedented decision — he said the mother could not see her 11-year-old son until she got the vaccine.

Read more on MSN.

Firlit is appealing the decision.

Now there may be readers who think “hooray for the judge” for using the power of the court to protect the child’s health. But if you agree that a judge, acting on their own initiative,  can order a parent to get vaccinated or else they can’t be with their child, would you be okay with a judge, on their own initiative, deciding that teachers cannot go into the school building unless they have been fully vaccinated?  What about a judge, on their own initiative, telling a woman that she must have a hysterectomy because she already has too many children that she cannot care for?  Or what if the judge, on their own initiative, tells a man that he had to have a vasectomy because he already has children who he has failed to support?

Yes, we have public health concerns.  No doubt about that.  But there are also privacy and autonomy issues, so before anyone punches the air in celebration of what this judge did, let’s take a breath and really think this through.

Category: CourtHealthcare

Post navigation

← New Mexico Attorney General Files COPPA Suit Against Game Developer
Privacy commissioner says N.S. Health violated privacy of program participants →

2 thoughts on “A judge asked a mother if she got the covid vaccine. She said no, and he revoked custody of her son.”

  1. Buford says:
    August 30, 2021 at 2:37 pm

    This story has changed. The Judge changed his ruling to allow visitation. Saw a 1pm update at Ars.

    She claims to have discussed getting vaccinated with her doctor and due to prior reactions to other vaccines, was advised NOT to get vaccinated.

    Some doctors are advising pregnant and women planning to become pregnant in the next year to not get vaccinated as well. My niece is about to give birth in a few weeks. She got vaccinated around 3 months pregnant after talking with a number of doctors, including her own mother. Just trying to show that there are some edge situations were yes/no vaccination is more complex.

    1. Dissent says:
      August 30, 2021 at 9:52 pm

      Thank you for the update. However, I still have questions as to how/why the judge even raised the question. Was it the case — as the mother subsequently claimed and the father seemed to confirm — that the issue of vaccination wasn’t before the court at all?

Comments are closed.

Now more than ever

Search

Contact Me

Email: [email protected]

Mastodon: Infosec.Exchange/@PogoWasRight

Signal: +1 516-776-7756

Categories

Recent Posts

  • The Markup caught 4 more states sharing personal health data with Big Tech
  • Privacy in the Big Sky State: Montana’s Consumer Privacy Law Gets Amended
  • UK Passes Data Use and Access Regulation Bill
  • Officials defend Liberal bill that would force hospitals, banks, hotels to hand over data
  • US Judge Invalidates Biden Rule Protecting Privacy for Abortions
  • DOJ’s Data Security Program: Key Compliance Considerations for Impacted Entities
  • 23andMe fined £2.31 million for failing to protect UK users’ genetic data

RSS Recent Posts on DataBreaches.net

  • CoinMarketCap Hacked, Scrambles to Remove Malicious Wallet Verification Popup
  • Montana Attorney General launches investigation into Lee Enterprises data breach
  • AT&T gets preliminary approval for $177 million data breach settlement
  • Aflac notifies SEC of breach suspected to be work of Scattered Spider
  • Former JBLM soldier pleads guilty to attempting to share military secrets with China
©2025 PogoWasRight.org. All rights reserved.