PogoWasRight.org

Menu
  • About
  • Privacy
Menu

Copyright owners cannot use DMCA to obtain ISP subscriber info: Court

Posted on May 11, 2015June 26, 2025 by Dissent

Their press release, below. I wonder how the other ISPs served by Rightscorp responded to the subpoenas. Did they fight or just turn over their customers’ information?

Birch Communications (“Birch”) a leading nationwide provider of communications, network and cloud services to small, mid-sized, enterprise and wholesale businesses, announced today a favorable ruling by the U.S. District Court in which a copyright litigant sought to use Digital Millennium Copyright Act (DMCA) subpoenas to obtain information about its customers’ online activities.

Rightscorp, a firm that represents assorted copyright holders, had served its subpoena to gain access to Birch’s customer information in an effort to identify customers claimed to have infringed its clients’ copyrighted content. Rightscorp had served similar subpoenas on dozens of other Internet Service Providers.

Acting on its customers’ behalf, Birch argued that it was not legally required to divulge the information and the court agreed. The DMCA did not provide any basis to require an Internet Service Provider in Birch’s position to open its files to private litigants. Because Birch acts simply as a conduit to Internet content, the court found that the rights owners could not use the DMCA subpoenas to obtain subscriber information.

On Tuesday, May 5, the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Georgia adopted the ruling and quashed Rightscorp’s subpoena.

“We safeguard our customer information and take privacy issues seriously,” said Birch President and Chief Executive Officer Vincent Oddo. “The U.S. District Court did the right thing by backing our view, and we’re very pleased to see that this case will serve to help protect our customers’ private information.”

“Our first order of business when anyone requests access to a customer’s private information is to refuse, absent a valid subpoena or court order, which we then scrutinize as we did with Rightscorp’s illegal subpoena in this matter,” said Christopher Bunce, Senior Vice President and General Counsel for Birch. “Rightscorp’s attempt to gain access to our customers’ data was in essence a piracy fishing expedition.”

SOURCE: Birch Communications

No related posts.

Category: BusinessCourtOnline

Post navigation

← Centre for Information Policy Leadership Comments on Brazil’s Draft Privacy Law
Two Men Who Breached Photobucket.com Indicted and Arrested on Conspiracy and Fraud Related Charges →

Search

Contact Me

Email: info[at]pogowasright.org
Security Issue: security[at]pogowasright.org
Mastodon: Infosec.Exchange/@PogoWasRight
Signal: +1 516-776-7756
DMCA Concern: dmca[at]pogowasright.org

Research Report of Note

A report by EPIC.org:

State Attorneys General & Privacy: Enforcement Trends, 2020-2024

Categories

Recent Posts

  • Modern cars are spying on you. Here’s what you can do about it.
  • Attorney General James and Multistate Coalition Secure $5.1 Million from Education Software Company for Failing to Protect Students’ Data       
  • EU Parliament committee votes to advance controversial Europol data sharing proposal
  • DHS offers “disturbing new excuses” to seize kids’ biometric data, expert says
  • California Adds Injunctive Relief to its Right of Publicity Statute and Extends Liability to Digital Replicas
  • DHS Gives Local Cops a Facial Recognition App To Find Immigrants
  • Phone location data of top EU officials for sale, report finds

RSS Recent Posts at DataBreaches.net

  • NCCIA arrests man over massive data breach involving millions of Pakistanis
  • Defense Contractors Are Silencing Their Cybersecurity Watchdogs
  • Fourth Circuit Weighs in on Standing in Data Breach Class Actions
  • ALT5 Sigma sues former consultant over alleged data breach
  • Is your cyberinsurance paid up? Are you sure?
©2025 PogoWasRight.org. All rights reserved.